Milgram Reenactment
RESULTS OF THE OBEDIENCE EXPERIMENT
"I am forever astonished that when lecturing on the obedience experiments in colleges across the country, I faced young men who were aghast at the behaviour of the experimental subjects and proclaimed they would never behave in such a way, but who, in a matter of months, were brought into the military and performed without compunction actions that made shocking the victims seem pallid. In this respect, they are no better and no worse than human beings of any other era who lend themselves to the purposes of authority and become instruments in its destructive processes."

Stanley Milgram

Milgram polled 40 psychologists before the experiment asking them at what point they believed the subject-teacher would break off, stop giving shocks and defy the experimenter.

The psychologists believed that less than 1% of the hpothetical subjects would administer the maximum 450 volts shock. They gave a figure of one subject in a thousand.

In practice 65% of subjects were fully obedient administering the maximum shock until they were told to stop. This percentage did not alter when the group of test subjects were women.

The following table shows the number of subjects who break off at each shock level:

Level:Volts No of subjects:malefemale
First Level15
Second Level30
Third Level45
Fourth Level60
Fifth Level75
Sixth Level90
Seventh Level105
Eighth Level120
Ninth Level1351
Tenth Level15054
Eleventh Level16511
Twelfth Level18012
Thirteenth Level195
Fourteenth Level2101
Fifteenth Level225
Sixteenth Level240
Seventeenth Level255
Eighteenth Level2702
Nineteenth Level2851
Twentieth Level30011
Twenty-first Level31532
Twenty-second Level3301
Twenty-third Level3451
Twenty-fourth Level3601
Twenty-fifth Level375
Twenty-sixth Level390
Twenty-seventh Level405
Twenty-eighth Level420
Twenty-ninth Level435
Thirtieth Level4502526
pecentage of obedience65%66%

The thresholds at The Tenth Level and the Twenty-first Level were most likely prompted by the Learners increasing discomfort.

At The Tenth level for the first time he asks to be released from the experiment and at the Twentieth level he refuses to answer any more questions. At the Twenty-first level he is heard to scream in absolute agony and demand once more to be released.

These statistics are probably some of the most significant in the history of psychology. They show the inadequacy of the profiling models that psychologists were working with at the time, and to a large extent reflect a wider set of assumptions about human nature.

The results surprised Milgram as much as the wider psychology community. Ultimately they force us to entirely reassess the susceptibility of human behaviour to conform and respond to authoritative social structures, irrespective of any moral or ethical dilemma that they face.